The start of a new year is always energizing, a time to reset, refocus, and recommit to the work that matters most. And this year, you have more tools, more data, and more proven strategies than ever before to connect with supporters and grow your mission.
With tighter budgets, higher donor expectations, and more data at your fingertips, success in 2026 depends on how well you align your strategy with the resources you already have. This year is the time to prioritize efficiency, deepen donor trust, and make smarter, more intentional decisions across every channel.
The six strategies below aren’t experimental or risky, they’re proven, practical, and ready to transform how you engage with donors.
Texting has moved from “interesting experiment” to “can’t ignore anymore.” The numbers tell the story: over 90% of adults own a smartphone, and one in three people checks a text within a single minute of receiving it. That kind of immediacy doesn’texist in any other channel.
The key to this strategy is treating texting not as a one-off ask, but as part of your omnichannel strategy that reinforces messages across email, mail, and digital.
The best texting programs balance frequency with relevance. They use personalized, conversational messages. They include visuals when appropriate. They test cadence to find the sweet spot between staying present and overwhelming supporters. And they integrate data across platforms so no donor gets duplicate outreach.
Start small, learn quickly, and scale what works. Texting isn’t replacing your other channels, it’s amplifying them and meeting donors exactly where they already are.
Read more: Texting is the channel nonprofits can’t ignore anymore
When resources are stretched, it’s tempting to cut acquisition and focus only on current donors. It feels like the safe choice. But organizations that protect acquisition—even during uncertain times—come out stronger in the long run.
Here’s the thing about cutting acquisition: the damage doesn’t show up right away. Year one looks fine. Maybe even great. You saved money, your loyal donors are still giving, and revenue stays steady. But every donor relationship you don’t start this year is a pipeline of long-term value you’ll never build. By the time the shortfall appears in your reports, you’re already two or three years behind.
The smarter approach? Get strategic instead of making blanket cuts. Use modeling to focus on prospects most likely to give and stick around. Protect your best channels and pause what isn’t working. Show leadership what happens not just this year, but in years two, three, and five if you stop building your donor base now.
Read more: Don’t shrink to survive: smarter fundraising under pressure
For more than a decade, nonprofit messaging leaned into urgency, conflict, and fighting against threats. It worked because supporters were emotionally charged and ready to mobilize. But something has shifted. Donors are worn down by constant alarm. They still care deeply, they’re just looking for messages that feel constructive instead of exhausting.
People want to give toward something, not just against something. They want to see progress, feel part of a community, and believe their contribution makes a tangible difference. Messages that highlight small wins, real stories, and collaborative impact resonate more than language anchored in crisis.
This doesn’t mean abandoning urgency altogether. But rather pairing honesty about the problem with a clear sense of direction. Show supporters the work that’s already unfolding. Use inclusive language like “together” and “our community” that positions them as partners in the mission rather than responders to the latest emergency.
Younger donors especially are drawn to messages that emphasize purpose, belonging, and agency. When they see momentum and can visualize their role in it, they stay engaged for the long haul.
Read more: Moving beyond us vs them: a turning point in nonprofit messaging
Most organizations track performance metrics religiously. But are those metrics revealing what you actually need to know? The difference between operational reporting and strategic insight often comes down to the questions you ask.
Instead of just tracking response rates and costs per donor, dig deeper. Are you over-messaging acquisition audiences and seeing diminishing returns? Could a fresh creative approach re-energize engagement with certain donor segments?
Organizations that move beyond surface-level metrics uncover game-changing patterns. They discover that some “costly” channels actually attract donors who give longer and upgrade more often. They identify lapsed donors who are still philanthropically active and ready to return with the right message. They spot segments where creative testing could yield significant improvement.
The real transformation happens when your KPIs align with long-term strategic priorities instead of short-term efficiency.
Read more: 5 questions every nonprofit should be asking right now
Lapsed donors aren’t lost causes! They just need the right message at the right time to come back. And when they do, they often give more than new donors and demonstrate higher lifetime value.
Success depends on three things: segmentation, timing, and channel strategy.
Segmentation: Recently lapsed donors (12-18 months) respond to light-touch reminders. Long-term lapsed supporters need a thoughtful reintroduction to your current work. High-value past donors are often worth personal outreach. And different segments respond to different channels based on their giving history.
AI cooperative database modeling can help. Instead of guessing which lapsed donors might return, AI can analyze patterns across your entire file to predict who’s genuinely ready to re-engage. It identifies donors who are still philanthropically active (just not with you), flags the optimal moment to reach out, and even suggests which message angles are most likely to resonate based on what originally motivated them. This kind of precision targeting means you’re not wasting resources on donors who aren’t ready while missing the ones who are.
Timing: The sweet spot for reactivation messaging usually opens around 12 to 15 months after the last gift. Too soon feels premature. Too late, and the connection has faded. And always verify your data before launching—nothing damages trust faster than sending “we miss you” messages to people who just gave.
Channel strategy: Multiple touches work better than single outreach. Begin with an impact story from their time as a supporter. Follow with a direct ask to renew their partnership. End with a final opportunity message. Keep the rhythm consistent but the content fresh.
And remember: the best reactivation strategy is preventing doners from lapsing in the first place. Watch for early warning signs like reduced engagement or skipped renewals, and reach out proactively when retention is still achievable.
Read more: Reactivation strategies that turn lapsed donors into loyal supporters
2025 had every organization scrambling to better understand where AI fits, how it works, and how to use it without chaos. 2026 will be about further determining where AI works and where it doesn’t, plus smart implementation.
Here’s what we know now: AI in fundraising can’t be about replacing the human work of building relationships. It can be about handling data analysis, pattern recognition, and routine tasks so your team can focus on what only humans can do: tell compelling stories and create authentic connections with supporters.
AI-powered modeling can predict donor behavior before it happens, optimize timing and messaging for individual preferences, and identify which lapsed donors are genuinely ready to return. It can help you move beyond static segments to dynamic indicators that update in real time based on actual behavior.
AI-powered analytics can forecast giving patterns months in advance, model different scenarios to test strategies before implementation, and provide continuous performance monitoring that enables mid-course corrections. These capabilities turn analytics from a backward-looking reporting function into a forward-looking strategic planning tool.
Practical applications are already delivering results: automatically improving data quality without manual work, generating personalized content at scale while maintaining your brand voice, spotting upgrade opportunities before they’re obvious, and flagging retention risks early when intervention is most effective.
The most successful implementations combine AI efficiency with human judgment. Technology amplifies your team’s capacity, but it can’t replace their expertise or intuition.
Read more: AI and the new age of fundraising
These six strategies work best when woven together into a cohesive approach that prioritizes donor relationships over transactional thinking.
When you meet supporters on the channels they prefer, invest in growing your donor base even during tight times, communicate with messages that inspire rather than exhaust, ask strategic questions that reveal real opportunities, bring lapsed donors back thoughtfully, and use technology to free up human capacity for relationship building, you’re not just improving this year’s KPIs. You’re building infrastructure for sustainable, long-term growth.
Your mission deserves more than reactive fundraising. It deserves a plan that builds momentum, deepens relationships, and creates the kind of sustainable support that carries your work forward for years to come.
Here’s to making 2026 your strongest fundraising year yet driven by intention, perspective and action.
Fill out the form below to connect with one of our nonprofit experts
We respect your privacy. By clicking Contact Us you are agreeing to Data Axle’s Privacy Policy and consent to Data Axle and its subsidiaries and affiliates using your email and phone number for marketing and analytical purposes, including to contact you regarding Data Axle products. You may opt out of all marketing communications at any time.